Keep in mind what’s usually going on in this scenario is attempted suicide by cop. A person who is impaired, distressed, or mentally ill is trying to provoke the police into shooting them by threatening bystanders and officers. The goal should be to prevent harm to the public, prevent harm to officers, and minimize harm to the subject in roughly that order. Here are some other options:
Taser - probably the best option when it works, but doesn’t work through heavy clothing
Batons - more likely to cause serious injury than 40mm rubber projectiles; officers have to get close to the armed subject
Small pepper spray - requires getting within a 1-2 second sprint of an armed subject, doesn’t actually disarm subject
Large pepper spray - officers have to go through mist to approach subject so they’re also impaired, doesn’t actually disarm subject
Batons - more likely to cause serious injury than 40mm rubber projectiles; officers have to get close to the armed subject
Absolutely not, those 40mm rubber projectiles are like a full strength hit from a baton. They will easily shatter an eye socket and cause brain damage if they hit in the head, they can crack ribs and cause damage to organs, best case scenario is they leave a really deep and nasty bruise… The kind that can lead to blood clots and threaten life and limb
If you get hit by one of these, you probably need immediate medical attention
With a baton, at least you have control. You could beat someone to death and crack skulls, but you could also not do that
These rounds are supposed to be fired at the ground and bounce up at someone, but police don’t usually follow that intended use, and when they hit people directly it’s absolutely a “less lethal” weapon
Why don’t we use people catchers? You can easily subdue anyone with a knife (from way outside knife range), and you can subdue people reliably with very low chance of injury to everyone involved. With 3+ people you can even pin old people in a standing position so they can be disarmed gently
They’re cheap to make, they’ve been used for thousands of years in many different places, and they’re very easy to use. Those are the tool they should be using for protestors, a riot shield wall in front and people catchers poking through like spears
It’s totally criminal that every squad car doesn’t have a couple in the trunk at all times, that’s the tool they should be using for crowd control and to subdue people having a mental health event
People keep writing grenade launcher, and I want to be clear: the police should not have grenades.
What they should have is a handful of officers equipped with a variety of options for apprehending or disabling a person that are less lethal than firearms.
The thing is, you can’t de-escalate someone who is not willing to de-escalate. All you can do is try to take the pressure off the situation and offer other options.
The net launcher is an interesting option I haven’t heard about police trying in that scenario. I’m not sure if that’s because it has been tried and doesn’t work, or because it hasn’t been.
I doubt a tranq gun is viable. It’s more dangerous than you might think, and it’s slow to take effect. That’s fine for a wild animal that doesn’t know what hit it, but a non-solution for an agitated person who responds by charging the police with a knife in an attempt to force them to shoot.
A therapist is often a good answer. It stops being a good answer when the subject brandishes a weapon at the therapist to force a police response.
Suggest some.
Keep in mind what’s usually going on in this scenario is attempted suicide by cop. A person who is impaired, distressed, or mentally ill is trying to provoke the police into shooting them by threatening bystanders and officers. The goal should be to prevent harm to the public, prevent harm to officers, and minimize harm to the subject in roughly that order. Here are some other options:
Absolutely not, those 40mm rubber projectiles are like a full strength hit from a baton. They will easily shatter an eye socket and cause brain damage if they hit in the head, they can crack ribs and cause damage to organs, best case scenario is they leave a really deep and nasty bruise… The kind that can lead to blood clots and threaten life and limb
If you get hit by one of these, you probably need immediate medical attention
With a baton, at least you have control. You could beat someone to death and crack skulls, but you could also not do that
These rounds are supposed to be fired at the ground and bounce up at someone, but police don’t usually follow that intended use, and when they hit people directly it’s absolutely a “less lethal” weapon
Why don’t we use people catchers? You can easily subdue anyone with a knife (from way outside knife range), and you can subdue people reliably with very low chance of injury to everyone involved. With 3+ people you can even pin old people in a standing position so they can be disarmed gently
They’re cheap to make, they’ve been used for thousands of years in many different places, and they’re very easy to use. Those are the tool they should be using for protestors, a riot shield wall in front and people catchers poking through like spears
It’s totally criminal that every squad car doesn’t have a couple in the trunk at all times, that’s the tool they should be using for crowd control and to subdue people having a mental health event
Catch poles do seem like a good idea. They work pretty well on dogs.
If you’re trying to prevent lone assailants killing people, does that mean that you expect police to patrol with 40 mm rotary grenade launchers?
People keep writing grenade launcher, and I want to be clear: the police should not have grenades.
What they should have is a handful of officers equipped with a variety of options for apprehending or disabling a person that are less lethal than firearms.
De-escalation training should be at the top there.
Absolutely.
The thing is, you can’t de-escalate someone who is not willing to de-escalate. All you can do is try to take the pressure off the situation and offer other options.
Do you know how far down the list a 40mm grenade launcher is outside of actual combat?
I can’t tell which side you’re shilling for right now.
Net launcher, tranq gun, therapist
The net launcher is an interesting option I haven’t heard about police trying in that scenario. I’m not sure if that’s because it has been tried and doesn’t work, or because it hasn’t been.
I doubt a tranq gun is viable. It’s more dangerous than you might think, and it’s slow to take effect. That’s fine for a wild animal that doesn’t know what hit it, but a non-solution for an agitated person who responds by charging the police with a knife in an attempt to force them to shoot.
A therapist is often a good answer. It stops being a good answer when the subject brandishes a weapon at the therapist to force a police response.
What about man catchers?