What bothers me is this rigid instruction “buy groceries and flowers”, why can’t it just be “get her something she would appreciate” and then there are different ways she reacts to whatever you buy
Well that makes total sense to me. Because these missions happen early on in the story and their purpose is mostly to teach you where the local businesses actually are. If they said to get her something nice players wouldn’t know what they can do. Like the grocery stores aren’t a shop menu. You walk around and pick things up off the shelf. It’s basically a tutorial for that. There’s also an explicit instruction to buy a necklace that gets used later in the story as collateral for something so that one needed to be said explicitly too.
Rockstar’s games are often praised for their feeling of freedom, but IME it typically does not apply when you’re on a story mission. You do the objectives one at a time exactly the way they drew them up, so that you see every cutscene and story beat exactly the way they want it, or you fail and get sent back to a checkpoint.
I haven’t played GTA6 but I don’t imagine this has changed.
I’m fine with that. I don’t mind linearity, if it is imperative to the story. Sometimes the story is the main aspect. But obviously if the game is advertised as very open then it might be against expectation, which is a whole other story. 😅
I haven’t installed RDR2 yet, is it advertised much as an open game?
Yeah nearly any game with a coherent story has to present that story linearly, otherwise the story just doesn’t make sense. Because stories, in general, are linear in nature.
I’m sure there’s some super cool exceptions to this that present a story non-linearly in a really creative and novel way that works. But I’m speaking in generalities here, and in general, stories are linear.
Breath of the Wild was a pretty cool example IMO. You don’t really need to visit the divine beasts in any particular order (although some might be implied considering the increase in enemy difficulty), but you also piece together a backstory as you find memories by exploring the wild, finding out what happened in the past. It’s pretty cool.
Same idea in Tears of the Kingdom as well. They know how to make games over at Nintendo, I tell you hwut.
What bothers me is this rigid instruction “buy groceries and flowers”, why can’t it just be “get her something she would appreciate” and then there are different ways she reacts to whatever you buy
Well that makes total sense to me. Because these missions happen early on in the story and their purpose is mostly to teach you where the local businesses actually are. If they said to get her something nice players wouldn’t know what they can do. Like the grocery stores aren’t a shop menu. You walk around and pick things up off the shelf. It’s basically a tutorial for that. There’s also an explicit instruction to buy a necklace that gets used later in the story as collateral for something so that one needed to be said explicitly too.
It’s an open world but they’ll be damned if they leverage it. It’ll have 200 species of squirrels tho.
Rockstar’s games are often praised for their feeling of freedom, but IME it typically does not apply when you’re on a story mission. You do the objectives one at a time exactly the way they drew them up, so that you see every cutscene and story beat exactly the way they want it, or you fail and get sent back to a checkpoint.
I haven’t played GTA6 but I don’t imagine this has changed.
All you had to do was follow the train
Crazy how linear stories get told linearly and want things done in a certain order.
Absolutely unplayable.
GTA 3 sends its regards.
Is this just the car bomb thing? Which was an oversight in development I think
RDR2 is an amazing game but it suffers heavily from this.
I’m fine with that. I don’t mind linearity, if it is imperative to the story. Sometimes the story is the main aspect. But obviously if the game is advertised as very open then it might be against expectation, which is a whole other story. 😅
I haven’t installed RDR2 yet, is it advertised much as an open game?
Yeah nearly any game with a coherent story has to present that story linearly, otherwise the story just doesn’t make sense. Because stories, in general, are linear in nature.
I’m sure there’s some super cool exceptions to this that present a story non-linearly in a really creative and novel way that works. But I’m speaking in generalities here, and in general, stories are linear.
Breath of the Wild was a pretty cool example IMO. You don’t really need to visit the divine beasts in any particular order (although some might be implied considering the increase in enemy difficulty), but you also piece together a backstory as you find memories by exploring the wild, finding out what happened in the past. It’s pretty cool.
Same idea in Tears of the Kingdom as well. They know how to make games over at Nintendo, I tell you hwut.
All I know is if fans start pushing for “non-linear” stories in games hard enough, what they will get is AI garbage.
You don’t HAVE to do all three things. You can do 0-3 and the relationship level will reflect that