• 7 Posts
  • 151 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle

  • Does this just create a gerontocracy where old members gatekeep forever?

    I don’t think it determines a gerontocracy (do people really care about upvotes?) and I don’t think it solves the problem you’re worried about either.

    How do you handle the first 30 days when no one has much weight?

    You show upvotes as a %, so if a post has +.01/-0 it’s still 100% upvoted.

    Would this actually prevent the decay, or just slow it down? Is there a simpler/better mechanism I’m missing?

    In your scenario, “hardcore” members leave because the signal/noise ratio is so low that the community is not worth following anymore.

    That has nothing to do with upvotes and all to do with mods failing to take down meme posts (assuming members don’t like memes).

    A community is its mods: if they allow low-effort posts (without meaning to) they are not doing their job properly, and that’s probably due to the job being too difficult and/or requiring too much effort.

    You could look into allowing older members to help moderate, or maybe into allowing mods to flag “trusted” users whose downvotes (possibly unbeknown to the users themself) will result in posts being taken down “for review”, or otherwise figure out some other way to help mods out, both when making up the rules (that too takes a lot of effort!) and when moderating posts/comments.

    A lemmy/reddit-style community is its mods. Think of how to help them be effective.




  • Picard adds IDs too (well, I think it only adds musicbrainz ids, per default anyway, but those are the only ones I care about).

    The lookup is automatic as well (you can review or intervene if it fails to identify the release).

    It also has a plugin for replay gain (I redo that step in my script anyways) and can be configured to delete any previous tags if you re-process music that you had previously tagged with some other software (IIRC it doesn’t clean them up per default).

    If you’ve not used it, I recommend giving it a try before deciding how to go on.


  • IDK if I’d recommend this to others, but I don’t trust unsupervised metadata lookup (I’m anal like that), so I lookup metadata with musicbrainz picard and then feed the files to beets only to keep my library organized.

    My beets doesn’t do any lookup (no lookup plugins are enabled, none_rec_action: asis, fetchart configured to only look at the local filesystem).















  • Your worth is not determined by abstract internet points.

    Sometimes people won’t get your message/point and downvote your contributions. The reason might be you not doing a good job at communicating (in my experience, it’s usually is that) or it might be them misunderstanding or you might not fit the community you are contributing to (eg. if your political view is not generally accepted in a community).

    Don’t worry about one of your posts/comments occasionally getting downvoted.

    If your contributions get downvoted consinsently (which seems to be the case from what you write? I don’t really are enough to go look at your account’s history), consider if continuing as you are is of any benefit to you and/or the community and if it’s still worth your time.

    In case, try seeing if it’s a style/tone/manners/respect thing that you maybe want to improve on or if it’s just not worth it and it’s better to go somewhere else or stop entirely.

    There is no law saying we must fit every community (I left communities and even an entire Lemmy instance for that).

    Also, this discussion is entirely OT since it has nothing to do with programming, and I am reporting it as such. If it’s downvoted or ends up being taken down (I hope so), it’s not because of some conspiracy against you.