• 1 Post
  • 81 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 6th, 2023

help-circle









  • You are being disingenuous here. I’m not shifting their argument. Here is their full comment with annotations -

    Sooner or later, a trans woman forced through male puberty by arbitrary rules/culture-war politics will snap

    Annotation 1: politicians making incorrect choices are going to force the hand of activists for this cause…

    and attempt to assassinate the PM or health minister.

    A2: which will inevitably lead to political violence against members of the government

    Then the other boot will come down: the Daily Mail will demand a crackdown, and the usual voices in the Guardian will join in, and the government will follow.

    A3: Then the media will blame the activists instead of themselves

    In what world is that not advocating for political violence?

    Let’s replace the issue in question and see if it still sounds ok to you:

    Sooner or later, a white nationalist forced to experience mass imigration due to arbitrary rules/culture-war politics will snap and attempt to assassinate the PM or home secretary. Then the other boot will come down: the Guardian will demand a crackdown, and the usual voices in the Daily Mail will join in, and the government will follow.

    Does the above sound acceptable?


  • In the UK we have had 2 MPs assassinated in the past 10 years. One Labour and one Conservative. Comments that essentially say, “The government should do what I want or there will be more political violence”, are inciting violence.

    The figleaf of being like “unless X happens, someone will do Y” is the same as 4chan maniacs threatening to commit acts of terror “in minecraft” or whatever.


  • He seems to have no filter whatsoever. His comments are inexcusable but he seemed to set himself up to broadcast every single thought that ever goes through his head to the entire world. I suspect there would be some clangers in there if I - or anyone else - spewed all of their halfbaked thoughts out all the time like that.

    Personally I’m never going to meet the guy and my opinion of him doesn’t particularly matter. That provides an opportunity to pick out the bits of his thoughts that I find interesting and leave out the bits that are crass. Appreciate not everyone has that luxury though, especially if they have been personally affected by one of the issues he’s crashed into like a bull in a china shop.