Thanks, that’s interesting to read about. While I’m not a web developer, there would seem to be two very large differences between them.
The Apple tokens were designed for a single purpose, reducing (or eliminating) CAPCHAs, with mobile devices especially in mind. It also is not a replacement, but rather an enhancement of an existing web standard.
It’s Apple, a company that makes their money by selling you things you actually want. Rather than Google, a company that gives you (or other companies) things (for free or discounted) so they can make money off of you.
It is especially obvious when Google has the literal first bullet-point in their “why we are developing this” as…
This trust is the backbone of the open internet, critical for the safety of user data and for the sustainability of the website’s business.
Followed by
These websites fund themselves with ads, but the advertisers can only afford to pay for humans to see the ads, rather than robots.
So yeah, Google can kindly go pound sand as far as I’m concerned.
Any chance you have a link or source for this? I usually keep up on tech news but don’t remember anything of this nature.
https://httptoolkit.com/blog/apple-private-access-tokens-attestation/
https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=huqjyh7k
Thanks, that’s interesting to read about. While I’m not a web developer, there would seem to be two very large differences between them.
The Apple tokens were designed for a single purpose, reducing (or eliminating) CAPCHAs, with mobile devices especially in mind. It also is not a replacement, but rather an enhancement of an existing web standard.
It’s Apple, a company that makes their money by selling you things you actually want. Rather than Google, a company that gives you (or other companies) things (for free or discounted) so they can make money off of you.
It is especially obvious when Google has the literal first bullet-point in their “why we are developing this” as…
Followed by
So yeah, Google can kindly go pound sand as far as I’m concerned.
Sure, but the technology is practically the same as Google’s, and could be used for the same purposes as what Google is proposing.
Even if Apple don’t say they’ll use it for ads, they might do so in the future. We don’t know their long-term plans.