• wheezy@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    2 days ago

    My dude. Elon musk sexually assaulted an employee on his private jet. Look, I’m autistic, I sometimes hyper-focus and miss the larger picture. So, I get it.

    But, holy shit, the way online comments do shit like you just did all the time. I don’t know where it comes from. But it’s a debate lord way of purposely misunderstanding the context of what is being talked about, looks for a single way to pretend someone is saying something else. And then defeating your own misunderstanding.

    The point I was making literally never had anything to do with the subordinate relationship or not. You’re arguing about IF he should have been let go. I’m not. I’m ok with him being let go for that.

    I’m talking about WHY he was let go. Because there is a massive contradiction in the weight between the crimes he is guilty of and the crimes other current tech CEOs are guilty of.

    This contradiction should scream to you that the narrative and explanation for his termination are not truthful. That’s my point.

    • wewbull@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 day ago

      Ok, so you think he was set up because he was in the way of the board. What do you think he was blocking and how does his departure free things up?

      • wheezy@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        16 hours ago

        I explained in other comments. But, first, a reminder. I’m writing my analysis. I’m not saying this is good or bad. People keep misunderstanding that. So I guess I gotta preface.

        The main suspicion is that he was open to trade with China and pushing Nvidia itself to start working on the software development side. The trade with China part is the part being pushed in the media; but has very little evidence around it apart from normal methods of avoiding trade restrictions that all capitalist do. It’s not to say it is good. CEOs should follow trade laws. But, none of them do. The whole world trade is made up of middlemen. So why is he special?

        Google and others have been developing in house chips to remove their dependence on Nvidia hardware. Nvidia started to do the same. Realizing that if this AI game keeps going they can’t stay in their hardware monopoly forever and world be forced to compete on both hardware (what they excell in) and software (what they do not).

        Haung wanted to capitalize on their current hardware monopoly and sell to China. A huge market that any capitalist is dying to enter. So, any evidence of him circumventing trade restrictions is within the same separation via middlemen, that all corporations engage in. It keeps them safe from consequences. Notice how he’s not being arrested. He just got pushed out.

        Haung was not only looking to have Nvidia move more towards direct competition, but, using their advantage in hardware to manufacturer application specific chips that would run on Nvidias own proprietary hardware and software. Software that would be largely developed from open source models.

        Now, a lot of people get this next part wrong. He was not looking to “put Chinese open source AI models” into Nvidia products. That’s not how it works for corporations. He was going to leverage the base structures of open source models that outperform many of the closed source models from American companies, but, develop on top of them to develop a completely closed source dependency. Closed hardware, closed software, and all the benefits open source software development giving free labor.

        The tech oligarchs aligned with the part of the Trump administration that are anti China. They see the writing on the wall for the life of the Trump admin, and are positioning themselves for an industry, in totality, that is non competitive. They want government mandates and restrictions on AI. But, not in the way the normal person does. Not stopping datacenters, no no no. They want to use the fear mongering of China to have the government ban open source AI models and basically place the keys to AI development in their hands and their hands only.

        They are trying to monopolize the entire tech industry into a closed system. All while using “national security” as a reason for them to be given that monopoly power.

        That is why I said that this is capitalist infighting. Haung was not playing this game. He was still playing a game of competition. Which died a long long time ago; and has really never been the goal of capitalism anyway.

        They admit all this shit. You just have to actually listen to them.

        https://youtu.be/3Fx5Q8xGU8k

        “Competition is for losers”

        • wewbull@feddit.uk
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          7 hours ago

          Ok, a few points.

          1. I tend to agree with you on Jensen’s motivation and actions. That doesnt mean his actions were in good judgement. He put himself and his company in a vulnerable position, which is the reason for his dismissal. Bad judgement.
          2. Yes, he’s been pushed out, and yes, he’s not been arrested. I don’t think he will escape interrogation. I fully expect him to be called before Congress and may well face criminal charges. The case has to be built against him by prosecutors, because right now it’s just journalists accusations which he’s then confirmed parts of. Basically I wouldn’t read much into the lack of legal action at this point. It will take time.
          3. It’s the board of Nvidia that has pushed him out. They’ve also refused to take him back, reinforcing that it’s their decision to not have him in the CEO role. They have plenty of reasons to make that decision without outside influence. And if the company strategy was to lobby for deeper relations with China what do they gain from removing him, unless his actions have forced them?
          4. The “hyperscalers” who are pursuing their own chips want to reduce their dependency on Nvidia for sure, but they have little reason to undermine the company/CEO that is bank-rolling a lot of what is happening in the AI field. Especially when the CFO who took over is known to be more fiscally prudent.
          5. Finally, it has been Nvidias software that has placed them in the position they have, more than their hardware. CUDA has been central. Other people with hardware solutions (AMD, Intel and now the hyper scalers) have been banging their head against the CUDA monopoly for a decade. You say others were scared of Nvidia moving into software. They were already there and killing their competition with it.

          Honestly I think you’re seeing conspiracy when there isn’t any. Yes. They all want a monopolized closed system, but this event wasn’t a battle of open Vs closed. It was a screw up and they’ve lost one of their generals.